I really do like deejaying weddings. Never thought I would. And the younger me, rocking four-to-five clubs a week in downtown NYC, would’ve scoffed at the idea ‘til he choked. (Even though I was making a pittance of what I make now, doing those all-night marathons for $150-$300.) Some weddings are more fun to do than others, of course. Some weddings don’t have as live an audience and dance floor as others. But luckily, those are far and few, between. And still…Some weddings give me moments that I’m still thinking about today. And right now.
“SOMETHING ABOUT YOU”
Level 42
“Play something they won’t wanna dance to” was my instruction from the catering manager at Blue Hill at Stone Barns, on the Rockefeller estate, a part of Stone Barns Center for Food & Agriculture, arguably the Hudson River Valley’s most sought-after wedding destination. The “vendor meal” is likely the best you’ll ever have, and usually sourced right on the premises…Meat, included. The catering manager made a point of saying something to the effect of, “we don’t want their Berkshire pig to get cold.” So, I obliged and put on a song from the decade they loved, a song from the decade they were just dancing to, a song that never gets a great reaction but is still, nonetheless, a great song. (One of my personal favorites from the era, come to think of it.) Unfortunately [for the catering manager], it was one of theirs, too—they went fucking nuts and kept dancing.
“DON’T FEAR THE REAPER”
Blue Oyster Cult
I have a Spotify playlist titled, “Songs I’ve Listened to at Least Seven Times in a Row.” I don’t know how it happens, but sometimes everything’s in its right place—the scenery, the moment, the feeling, the energy, the perfect song—and six rewinds unfold. Sometimes more. (11 is the record. Billie Eilish’s “Birds of a Feather.” When I was lifting in the gym. Don’t ask. Shit happens. I was in my feelings…in my reps.) Anyways, this Rock-god record is on there. I just did a wedding where the bride and groom said this song was a personal fave of theirs. You could imagine my delight. I played the song, they did this cute little dance, just the two of them, and lemme tell you…Had Halloween not passed, I would’ve joined them [and ruined their moment].
“ALL THE SMALL THINGS”
blink-182
I never linked blink-182. They were too soft for me at the time, to nerdy, too sweet for rock. But this song is decent, and people love it, so it gets played. I deejayed a wedding at West Point’s Thayer Hotel, played this song, and for the first time in my career, I made a groom cry. It was the last song of the night, everybody was on the dance floor losing their shit, a proper rager, this song drops, and you felt the room shift into another dimension—it’s not just a huge banger for the millennials, but the perfect song to end on, as it’s about appreciating all the little things in a great relationship. So, you got the bride and groom in the middle of a circle of all their friends and family, everyone’s going ballistic, cheering, clapping, jumping, and the I see the groom rubbing his eyes constantly. An allergic reaction? Now? To what?? (Does somebody have an epi-pen?) Nope. He was literally crying. Later, on the rooftop, I saw someone giving him eyedrops. He came up to me, sat down, and said he couldn’t believe what I did to him. At your motherfucking service.
“PIANO MAN”
Billy Joel
I pledged the Phi Chapter of Zeta Psi at NYU in 1995. I wanted to have a family, a home away from home, brothers. It was one of the best choices I’ve ever made, and I went on to make some of the closest friends I still have, to this day. Not-to-mention the parties. Absolutely ridiculous keggers. People on the bar, people on chairs, on couches, in the bathroom, in the stairwells, on the floor, in the rooms, keg-stands, whip-its, joints…It was absolute, delicious chaos. We resided on the top floor of 3-5 Washington Place, a huge, almost block-long loft with nine rooms and 18 brothers, and you know who getting his first taste of deejaying. (It was rudimentary. Two CD players, a mixer, stop one song and push “play” on the other at just the right time.) There were two songs that were must-play anthems at the time. One was Capleton’s “Tour (Remix,” and the other was “Piano Man.” Every party had to end with a drunken circle of bros singing “Piano Man.” I couldn’t help but relive those moments at this wedding at the Foundry in Long Island City where the bride and groom insisted on playing it at the end. (See here.) No fricking problem.
“BLACK”
Pearl Jam
Before Zeta Psi, my band of brothers was an outstanding group of men that had a summer house down the Shore. They were men of valor, of integrity, of love and code, and of underage drinking. Lots of it. (I’m convinced I got ulcerative colitis from being introduced to Jagermeister at too early an age.) They were originally friends with my older brother, but after he brought is younger to tagalong once, that younger brother became a fixture. (I would frequently sleepover. The sound of them lining up one by one to hurl into the toilet the next morning…Peak.) The music, the girls, the fun, the Jager…It shaped me. (No lie.) And the last song of each party where these bros locked arms and sang like dying silverback gorillas was this one. Imagine my delight when one of them said they were getting remarried and wanted me to DJ. I almost did it for free, knowing what the last song would be.
“HIGHER”
Creed
Another one. Way too clean. Too glossy. Too much hair gel. The power chords could do little wrinkle the Armani X outfits. Where are the ripped tee shirts? The plaids? The crusty jeans? The green teeth? The years of abuse?? Come on, son. This ain’t it. UNTIL it was, at a wedding at the Loeb Boathouse at Central Park. The grooms’ friends said that “Higher” should be the last song, as it’s a personal fave of theirs and the groom’s and bride’s, and they were right. (Proof.) I kinda like the song, too. I just try not to think of the Armani shirts.
“YOU GET WHAT YOU GIVE”
New Radicals
Again…Completely missed me, completely off the radar, too soft, no edge, too sweet, nah I’m good, and then a bride and groom requests it as a last song and everyone’s going nuts and, in their feelings, singing every word, getting emotional, more allergic reactions and teary eyes, and now I’m getting in my feelings…why??? And now it’s a must. At home, too. Goosebumps—the lyrics, the video, the vibe, the idea, saying “goodbye” to something you really don’t wanna say “goodbye” to, but something you’ll never really leave. It’s just too heavy, man. Too deep for this aging deejay. Damn what a big choon.
“FADE INTO YOU”
Mazzy Star
It was my second wedding at the Crystal Springs Resort in Hamburg, NJ. My wife came with me on this one; we stayed the night, she got a massage, and I almost crapped my pants…twice. The first time, I was making my way towards the outdoor event hall, and somebody came running in the opposite direction, yelling “BEAR!” I turned around and ran as fast as I could with all my gear. The second time was the next morning. I ate some old gelato or something, and en route home, couldn’t find a public restroom. I ended up sneaking into a weirdly deserted police station in Tuxedo, NY, and spilling my guts in a bathroom. Somebody had just been in there, too—the floor was wet and a porno mag was opened on the floor next to the toilet. Maybe they got called away on an emergency. ANYWAYS…It was one of those awesome gigs where everyone was dancing all night, start to finish, but earlier on, the bride and groom’s first dance song sounded a lot like Mazzy Star’s, so I played it after, and couples who were supposed to be in line for food started slow dancing, and thanked me afterwards. I was in my 90s teen-heartbreak feelings.
“DON’T BRING ME DOWN”
Electric Light Orchestra
I grew up on ELO. Anytime I got in my dad’s ’84 Honda Accord to go pretty much anywhere, it was ELO. I sang it around the house until my family got annoyed (except my dad). I sang it in the shower. I sang it in school. The sound of “Out of the Blue”’s 8-track tape pushed into the tape holder…That heavy click…Pure anticipation. The music has so many layers. So lush. So melodic and rich and robust and gorgeous. Jeff Lynn was brilliant. You can imagine my delight when a recent bride asked for this record for the dance floor. Of course, I knew few would recognize it, and most wouldn’t wanna dance to it,and I made that clear to her. But she didn’t care. During the dancing segment of the night, I played it, and it cleared the floor completely, except for her. There was the bride, drink in hand, eyes closed, dancing completely alone to “Don’t Bring Me Down.” Coulda been me.
“SANDSTORM”
Darude
I did it!
I finally got someone so crazy they took take their shirt off at the wedding!
Thank you, Darude!
Herbert Holler has been a full time, professional DJ based in NYC for over 25 years. He’s played some of the biggest dance floors in NYC and has been seen on “The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon.” His legendary dance party, Herbert Holler’s Freedom™ Party, is the longest running throwback night in history. For more information, including private events, feel free to visit his Website, Instagram, or shoot an email to herbert@herbertholler.com.
